Do You Really Know Which Customers Are Making You Money? | United Accounting Solutions | Michael Archbold

Do You Really Know Which Customers Are Making You Money?

Knowing Your Customers Is Vital To Sustained Revenue Growth

Your largest customers are not necessarily your most profitable customers. Revenue is only part of the equation. Labor requirements, discounts, special accommodations, collection efforts, and payment timing can dramatically affect how valuable a customer relationship actually is. By analyzing profitability at the customer level, Business Owners can identify which relationships deserve greater attention, determine where pricing or service changes may be necessary, and focus future growth efforts on attracting more of their best customers. If your bookkeeping does not provide enough detail to answer these questions, improving your accounting and reporting structure may be the first step.

Do You Really Know Which Customers Are Making You Money?

It is easy to assume that your biggest customers are also your most profitable customers.

That assumption can be wrong.

A customer who generates significant revenue may also require substantially more time, more administrative work, more discounts, more follow-up, and more attention than your other customers. Once those additional costs are considered, the relationship may not be nearly as profitable as it appears on the surface.

For Business Owners, understanding profitability at the customer level can reveal opportunities that a traditional Profit & Loss Statement may never show.

Revenue Does Not Equal Customer Profitability

Most Business Owners can probably identify their largest customers based on sales.

But which customers actually generate the most profit?

Those are two very different questions.

Consider two customers that each generate $50,000 of annual revenue.

Customer A consistently purchases standard products or services, pays the normal price, requires relatively little support, and pays invoices promptly.

Customer B generates the same $50,000 but regularly requests discounts, requires custom work, consumes considerably more employee time, and routinely pays invoices late.

Their revenue may be identical.

Their profitability almost certainly is not.

This is why evaluating customers strictly by sales volume can create a distorted picture of where your business is actually making money. Intuit’s discussion of client profitability similarly focuses on determining what a customer contributes after considering the actual costs required to service the relationship.

How Much Time Does Each Customer Require?

Labor is often one of the largest expenses in a business, but it can also be one of the hardest costs to associate with individual customers.

Some customers are relatively easy to serve.

Others require repeated phone calls, additional meetings, revisions, troubleshooting, administrative work, or specialized attention from employees.

None of those activities may appear as a separate expense labeled with the customer’s name.

But they still cost money.

A customer generating $10,000 of revenue while requiring 20 hours of employee time can be significantly more profitable than a customer generating $15,000 while requiring 100 hours of employee time.

That makes employee time an important part of customer profitability analysis.

Business Owners should consider whether their accounting and operational systems provide enough information to understand how much time and effort different customer relationships actually require. Intuit notes that meaningful customer profitability analysis may include not only direct expenses, but also employee time, overhead, write-offs, and other costs associated with servicing an account.

Discounts and Special Accommodations Add Up

Discounts can sometimes make good business sense.

The problem begins when exceptions quietly become routine.

Perhaps a longtime customer always receives a discount.

Another customer routinely requests expedited service without paying an additional charge.

Someone else receives free delivery, extended support, waived fees, customized reporting, or other accommodations that most customers do not receive.

Individually, those concessions may not appear significant.

Collectively, they can substantially reduce the profitability of the relationship.

Customer profitability analysis forces Business Owners to look beyond the invoice total and ask a more important question:

What does it actually cost us to generate this revenue?

Slow-Paying Customers Have a Cost Too

A profitable sale is considerably less helpful if you have to wait months to collect it.

Slow-paying customers create additional administrative work and can place unnecessary pressure on cash flow.

Your employees may spend time sending reminders, making collection calls, researching disputed invoices, or coordinating payment arrangements.

Meanwhile, your business may already have paid employees, vendors, rent, utilities, and other expenses related to delivering the product or service.

The customer effectively receives extended financing from your company—whether you intended to provide it or not.

That does not automatically mean a slow-paying customer is unprofitable.

But payment behavior should absolutely be part of the profitability discussion.

Identify Your Most Valuable Relationships

One of the biggest benefits of customer-level profitability analysis is discovering which relationships deserve more attention.

Your most valuable customers may not necessarily be the largest.

They may be customers who:

  • Purchase consistently
  • Pay full price
  • Require relatively little servicing
  • Pay promptly
  • Generate repeat business
  • Refer additional customers
  • Purchase higher-margin products or services

Those are relationships worth protecting and expanding.

Understanding what your best customers have in common can also improve your marketing strategy.

Instead of simply pursuing more customers, you can pursue more customers who resemble your most profitable customers.

That is a much more powerful growth strategy.

What About Your Least Profitable Customers?

This analysis can occasionally produce uncomfortable results.

You may discover that a customer you have served for years is producing very little profit.

That does not necessarily mean you should immediately end the relationship.

Instead, it gives you information you can use to make better decisions.

Perhaps pricing needs to increase.

Maybe certain services should carry additional charges.

Discounts might need to be reconsidered.

Payment terms could be tightened.

Or the way your team services the account could become more efficient.

In some situations, however, the numbers may reveal that a relationship simply does not make economic sense.

Business Owners should not be afraid to recognize that every dollar of revenue is not equally valuable.

Can Your Bookkeeping Actually Answer the Question?

Here is where many Business Owners encounter a problem.

They want to know which customers are generating the most profit, but their bookkeeping system was never designed to provide the answer.

Income may be properly recorded.

Expenses may be categorized correctly.

Financial statements may even appear completely accurate.

But if the accounting system does not capture enough detail about customers, projects, labor, discounts, expenses, and other relevant activity, determining customer-level profitability can become extremely difficult.

The IRS emphasizes that good business records help Business Owners monitor the progress of the business, prepare financial statements, identify sources of income, and keep track of expenses. A technically accurate set of books is important, but management reporting may require a greater level of detail depending on the questions a Business Owner wants answered.

The IRS also explains in Publication 583, Starting a Business and Keeping Records, that a business may choose a record keeping system suited to its needs as long as it properly reflects income and expenses.

Good bookkeeping should do more than tell you what happened.

It should help provide the information needed to make better business decisions.

At United Accounting Solutions, we help Business Owners organize their bookkeeping and financial reporting so they can better understand where their money is actually being made—and where profitability may be disappearing.

If you cannot confidently identify your most profitable customers, it may be time to take a deeper look at the numbers behind those relationships.

I hope you found this information helpful. If you have questions about your finances or would like guidance tailored to your situation, I’d be happy to talk. With years of experience helping individuals and businesses gain clarity and confidence in their numbers, my goal is to help you make informed decisions and move forward with confidence. Feel free to call me anytime at 260-579-1516 or email me at mike@unitedaccountingsolutions.com.

Michael J Archbold
Accountant
United Accounting Solutions
8101 Coldwater Rd
Fort Wayne, IN 46825
c. 260-579-1516
e. Mike@UnitedAccountingSolutions.com
w. www.UnitedAccountingSolutiions.com

Know someone who could use clarity and confidence in their finances? I’m NEVER too busy for your referrals.

United Accounting Solutions – Do You Really Know Which Customers Are Making You Money?…

… brought to you by Michael Archbold and United Accounting Solutions.

The consummate professional, Michael Archbold brings a diversified background to the world of accounting. Born and raised in Fort Wayne, IN, Mike received bachelors degrees in Accounting in 1997 from the Indiana University Kelley School of Business and Information Technology in 2005 from Indiana Wesleyan University. Mike has more than 25 years of experience in accounting and real estate investing/sales.